Tue 4 Oct 2016
A Book! TV Show!! Review by Michael Shonk: ADAM HALL – Tango Briefing.
Posted by Steve under Reviews , TV Espionage & Spies[16] Comments
ADAM HALL (ELLESTON TREVOR) – The Tango Briefing. Doubleday, US, hardcover, 1973. Dell, paperback, 1974. First published in the UK by Collins, hardcover, 1973.
QUILLER. “Tango Briefing.” BBC One; September 5, 1975. Written by Adam Hall, based on characters he created. Cast: Michael Jayston as Quiller and Moray Watson as Angus Kinloch. Guest Cast: Nigel Stock as Loman, Prunella Gee as Diane, Reg Lye as Chirac and Paul Angelis as Vickers Designer: Peter Blacker. Produced by Peter Graham Scott. Directed by David Sullivan Proudfoot.
My experience with Quiller is limited. I began with the disappointing film QUILLER MEMORANDUM, then the good but nothing special book NINTH DIRECTIVE. Recently I read the book TANGO BRIEFING and watched a rare copy of the British TV episode based on the book.
Both versions of TANGO BRIEFING were written by Adam Hall (Elleston Trevor) and featured Quiller searching for a lost plane in the Sahara desert. A mission that had already cost lives.
I enjoyed the book, and even though it was fifth in the Quiller series it felt like an introduction story to the character. Narrated in first person by the character Quiller, and while he remained a self-effacing enigma, the book was filled with many details about his job and his life (which amounted to the same thing).
Actor Michael Jayston (TINKER TAILOR SOLDIER SPY, 1979) was well chosen for the role, better than the film’s version played by George Segal. Quiller has a lack of respect and trust for authority figures. Segal played it with more Connery-as-Bond-like humor, while Jayston had a meaner, rude touch.
The book TANGO BRIEFING was a well-written thriller full of tension and excitement. The TV episode was loyal to the book, but due to time and budget, made a few changes, changes that stripped the story of much of its suspense and drama.
Few have ever seen the QUILLER TV series. Even in the collectors market the series is difficult to find. Apparently only three episodes of the series thirteen survive. Luckily TANGO BRIEFING was one of them. The short-lived series aired only once on the BBC and was never shown again. Its episodes met the same fate of many BBC genre series of that era such as DOCTOR WHO, and ADAM ADMANT LIVES (reviewed here ) when the stuffy old men at BBC in a fit of snobbery purged its entertaining non-socially conscious series from its warehouse.
Anyone aware of the TV series probably best remembers it for its popular theme song written by Richard Denton and Martin Cook (HONG KONG BEAT, THE GREAT EGG RACE).
The song was released on a 45 record with “General Direction†from QUILLER soundtrack on the B-side.
The mission in TANGO BRIEFING was to recover the cargo of a downed plane in the Sahara desert. The mission had gone bad and The Bureau sends Quiller in to complete the job. He was not told why the plane’s cargo was so important or what it was, but he realized it was vital to the British government that he reach the plane before the local Algerian government or anyone else who might be looking for it.
His “director†on the mission was Loman. Loman would make the plans and handle all the details while “the executive†or “ferret†Quiller was out in the field. The two had worked together before and neither liked the other or approved of the other’s methods.
After Quiller met with Loman there is an attempt on his life. In the book Quiller barely escaped alive and was physically weakened for the rest of the adventure, while in the TV episode he escapes with no injuries as a young native sets off the trap. I am not sure why writer Hall made the change but it was an important one.
The book Quiller is a superspy, a man able to do what few men can. Forced to overcome his injuries, Quiller goes beyond the average spy. From watching the three available episodes, the TV series producers seemed to want to make Quiller a more fallible realistic human but keeping Quiller’s arrogance and attitude. Unlike the book Quiller the TV Quiller was an unlikable one-dimensional character.
Every scene in the book added to the risks for Quiller, with time running out and others getting closer. TANGO BRIEFING the book makes powerful use of time and its passing. But the TV episode limited by its hour length could not fit it all in and what was used often felt contrived.
Four of the book’s characters made it from book to TV episode. Besides Loman, the other member of Quiller’s support team was inexperienced radio operator Diane. The character served a better purpose in the book with Quiller’s disapproval of her inexperience and concern for her youth adding tension and jeopardy to the story. The character of Diane was badly misused in the TV episode. TV Quiller was fast to forgive her inexperience and shook her hand accepting her to the team, there were G-rated hints of possible romance, and a scene was clumsily dropped in where she beat up a bad guy who attacked her in the radio room.
Two local characters, Chirac, the man who flies Quiller to the desert, and Vickers, the freelance oil driller, make it to the TV episode. Chirac goes from the book’s lovable old ex-war hero to the TV episode’s weak link. Vickers was a minor character in the book. His appearances in the TV episode were obviously forced by the need to foreshadow the TV’s version different ending.
Then there is the desert search for the plane that takes up much of the book and the TV episode. The TV version greatest mistake was to abandon the book’s first person narration. The scenes in the desert are among the highlights of the book. Quiller’s narration allows us inside the character, fleshing him out. We may not learn his real name or details of his past but we do learn how he thinks and feels. This is where Quiller becomes someone we care about.
In the TV episode, plot information and characterization was limited to the radio conversations between Quiller and Diane and Loman at the radio base in Kaifra. Without Quiller’s explaining his thoughts and exploring the details of his situation, we never feel his fear and stress as we do reading the book. This left the story in the TV version underdeveloped and less powerfully dramatic.
While the QUILLER theme song is great, the episode soundtrack was awful and let down the episode. The desert scenes could have worked better if the soundtrack had supplied the emotions of the scenes that the narration gave readers in the book.
Director David Sullivan Proudfoot (WARSHIP) did his best. His highlight was a shot of the shadow against a desert dune of a vulture circling over an unconscious Quiller.
The two versions differed in endings. The book’s final scenes would have made an exciting end for a theatrical film. The TV ending was weak, contrived and obvious.
The book is well worth reading. It is hard to believe the same man who wrote the book wrote the TV version. I suspect Hall’s final draft was not the final shooting script.
SOURCES:
Action TV: http://www.startrader.co.uk/Action%20TV/guide70s/quiller.htm
The Unofficial QUILLER website http://www.quiller.net
The Encyclopedia of TV Spies by Wesley Britton (BearManor Media, 2009)
October 4th, 2016 at 7:11 pm
I like Segal, but he was nearly as miscast in QUILLER MEMORANDUM as Dean Martin was in the two-bit Matt Helm movies.
October 4th, 2016 at 8:06 pm
Segal stars in my favorite movie of all time WHO’S KILLING THE GREAT CHEFS OF EUROPE? and a favorite TV series MURPHY’S LAW, yet I find he usually overplays his roles.
I need to read more of the Quiller books but I find more anger than humor in the character. The movie didn’t know what it wanted to be a Bond thriller or a straight serious spy film. The TV series also had a problem getting ahold of who Quiller really is.
October 5th, 2016 at 3:40 am
I actually prefer the film THE QUILLER MEMORANDUM to any of the books. I can see I shall have to wait for Fashion to catch up with me.
October 5th, 2016 at 1:43 pm
Dan, I think more people know Quiller from the film than the books. I found the movie just another serious spy film among the many that were popular at the time. I didn’t dislike it I was disappointed it wasn’t different or special. The NINTH DIRECTIVE had that same “just another spy” book feeling for me.
Hall’s writing in TANGO BRIEFING surprised me. He was able to make this reader feel what the characters were going through.
As for the rest of the books, I might find them as average as NINTH DIRECTIVE or as entertaining as TANGO BRIEFING. Oddly, while I liked TANGO BRIEFING I am in no hurry to read the rest. Quiller the character is so much a mystery there is a blandness to him.
October 5th, 2016 at 4:55 pm
I can just about remember the series from when it was orginally shown. The show had three scripts from the late, great Brian Clemens. One of the surviving episodes is apparently by him, based on a script that he wrote for the original run of MISSION IMPOSSIBLE which was never made. Whether it’s true to the spirit of the original books of not, I’d really love to see that episode!
October 5th, 2016 at 6:21 pm
Bradstreet and for those curious about the series
The other two episodes surviving are “Price of Violence†and “Any Last Questions.â€
“Price of Violence†(August 29, 1975) Written by Michael J. Bird – Directed by Peter Graham Scott – SUPPORTING CAST: Sinead Cusack – GUEST CAST: Ed Bishop, Marc Zuber and Judy Liebert *** After a blown assignment Quiller takes a bodyguard job that is more dangerous than he knows.
The best of the three surviving episodes and pilot episode where all the characters are introduced including a possible love interest for Quiller in Roz a lady lawyer who is close to Angus, Quiller’s Control. Great soundtrack.
“Any Last Question†(September 12, 1975) Written by Brian Clemens – Directed by Michael Ferguson – GUEST CAST: Edward Judd, Sheila Brennan and Ronald Lacey *** An English spy is caught and sentenced to die by firing squad. Quiller must rescue the Englishman but also convince everyone that the man died by firing squad.
The episode featured a rejected MISSION IMPOSSIBLE script that was too unbelievable to work but had a couple of interesting twists including a brilliant one at the end. This is not the only time Clemens recycled an old script (he did it for THE AVENGERS). It is a simple way to get ahead of production demands of getting the series done on schedule. But this was totally wrong for the series.
Yes, Brian Clemens (THE AVENGERS and nearly every other British genre series in the 60s and 70s) wrote three episodes. Others to write for the series included Anthony Read (DR WHO) Michael j Bird (WHO PAYS THE FERRYMAN?), Roger Parkes (BLAKE’S 7), and David Weir (MOGUL)
Directors included Peter Graham Scott (THE ONEDIN LINE)
Michael Ferguson (SANDBAGGERS), Raymond Menmuir (THE AVENGERS), and Gerald Blake (DR WHO)
Among the guest cast were Peter Graves, John Rhys-Davies, Julian Glover, George Cole, and Michael Latimer.
October 5th, 2016 at 9:00 pm
Hall/Trevor was unusual in that the Quiller books got better as time moved along. The series got leaner and smarter, and it was lean and smart to begin with.
Ironically Jayston played James Bond in the BBC Radio adaptation of YOU ONLY LIVE TWICE.
October 5th, 2016 at 10:07 pm
7. David, you encourage me to try another QUILLER book.
October 6th, 2016 at 5:40 pm
Michael,
Some of the later Quiller’s are very good. QUILLER BARRACUDA is a good one.
October 7th, 2016 at 12:49 am
Thanks, David. I’ll give that one a try.
August 6th, 2020 at 8:25 pm
Just found all the 13 episodes.
Kind of disappointing after having read all the books.
Whoever said the books are bland knows not whereof he speaks.
Each one was so exciting I couldn’t put them down, and usually finished one in a night.
August 6th, 2020 at 9:36 pm
Frank
I also found one seller who is selling copies of the complete series on DVD. It’s amazing that they all still exist. Only problem is that he wants $45 for the set. I can’t afford that, so it’s back to looking some more.
August 23rd, 2021 at 2:46 am
I’ve loudly announced myself before around here, as a devout Adam Hall/Elleston Trevor fan, I’ve stated it plainly on other Adam Hall threads on MysteryFile. Ain’t no news ’bout that.
Lots to touch-on in this thread, but first of all let me commend the scrutiny and perspicacity of the book/TV series reviewer for such a point-by-point dissection of the Quiller franchise. Meticulous!
Backstory: since I was a wee tyke I’ve always avidly gobbled up thriller paperbacks. This predilection still puts me only ‘ankle-high’ to the reg’lar blokes on this site, who make a lifelong pursuit of thriller-reading. I only speak from a quarter of their experience.
Nevertheless, I don’t hesitate in the least to say that the Quiller novels are the most exciting reads I may have ever encountered outside of Hammett. Or else, horror yarns from Stephen King, Shirley Jackson, etc.
Hall’s Quiller romps are so good they make me short-of-breath and goggle-eyed, as Hammett does. But Hammett’s bibliography is slender and Adam Hall gives me twenty full-length Quiller adventures.
For my money, Elleston Trevor is the post-WWII Hammett; as well as an improvement on Ian Fleming’s Bond. If there’s anyone else this good an action-writer, I’d sure like to know about him. Pound-for-pound, Trevor matches up to Maugham/LeCarre/Deighton/Greene/Ambler/McCarry/Littell in that he delivers the full-blooded action which all those other giants, de-prioritize.
Adam Hall/Elleston Trevor writes espionage; he can be as slick and psychological as anyone else in that realm, but what he also delivers is the ‘berserker’ violence I’ve only found elsewhere, in the pages of Dashiell Hammett or Paul Cain. Freaky, disturbing violence.
As stated above: not being as well read as this site’s true aficionados, my remarks aren’t ‘blanket statements’, I’m only speaking from my own reading history.
Back on topic. Like many others, I too was introduced to Quiller from the quirky neo-Nazi flick with George Segal, deft screenplay by John Mortimer (or someone as good as John Mortimer, was it John Osborne?); and co-starring Alec Guinness.
Was Segal the very best casting one could ask for? No, but George Segal is a darn good actor and he acquitted himself ably in this, as he did so many other roles. I can’t comprehend the assertion that he was a ‘scenery-chewer’. Segal played such a diversity of characters, under a diversity of directors. Brutes, cads, lovers, oafs, weaklings, schleps, psychos. Other stars might have done better, but many might have done less, than did Segal as ‘Quiller’. I must admit I like the choice of Michael Jayston as a successor.
This is not to excuse ‘Quiller Memorandum’ which is a perhaps-too-subtle-for-the-screen type of spy novel. The source material was ill-used. Even the novel is not quite on firm-footing. Quiller was still ‘finding his form’ in his first book; and it showed in the movie adaptation. There’s weaknesses. But there’s also strengths.
This is where I started with the Elleston Trevor ‘Quiller’ novels. First, I investigated whether the earliest book matched up with the movie. Found them both good in their own way; not so much for the plots but for the quality writing and the cleverness. At one and the same time, he’s a thinking man’s hero and he’s also an adrenalin-junkie. He’s soft-spoken, and he’s brutal.
Movie+Book: Quiller not carrying a gun.
Book: Quiller knowing how to make his body ‘go limp’ and ‘faint’. Movie+Book: Quiller is adept at surviving interrogations. Movie: Quiller brawling with six Neo-Nazis. Book: Quiller’s hatred of Nazis; (never followed-up on). Movie+Book: Quiller multi-lingual skills.
Results: mixed. But howsoever the franchise began, it’s the book series which gains speed and force. The books surge forward.
Every single one displays innovation, to my eyes.
In ‘Sinkiang Executive’ Quiller must train and then return a captured Mig back across Russian air defense all for the sake of crash-landing near a contact he must meet near the Manchurian border.
In ‘Ninth Directive’, Quiller must stop an international assassin from making his next kill in Bangkok. What is unusual here is the assassination taking place in the middle of the book! The middle of the book! How some claim this is an ‘average read’, I cannot grasp.
Next: ‘Tango Briefing’ is another exceptionally subtle and well-done installment of the ‘Quiller’ franchise.
The stark locale recalls ‘Flight of the Phoenix’ –how this British author knows the African desert so well, I’ve no idea.
But the novel has many eerie, desolate settings I’ve never found in any other thriller, and the novel also has some extraordinary action sequences which explode in these settings.
I don’t know how –or why –anyone ever thought it could be adapted into a TV series. Whether in Tangier, Bangkok, or Siberia, Elleston Trevor has a keen eye for visual detail; but I would think that without a voice-over any adaptation would fail.
Quiller is a 90% internal character. It’s part of his trade-craft to go as unnoticed as possible. He rarely beds women; gambles; drinks. He lives for missions; trusts nobody. A nihilistic figure.
Now, a key scene in ‘Tango Briefing’ which made me sit up in awe. Middle of the book. Seems like the same old ordinary espionage tropes. Spies tailing each other.
I can’t convey the shock of reading this grisly-turning scene here in my remarks. It takes place on a vastly empty stretch of highway in North Africa. Quiller has just lost a car chase with his pursuers.
If it were a Fleming novel, James Bond would simply let himself be accosted by the three thugs who ambush him. He would light a cigarette, make a jeer, and allow himself to be led off to Blofeld’s headquarters for a meeting with the arch-enemy of Britain.
But Quiller is having none of it. This is the stamp of all his action scenes. 180-degrees-opposite of the flashy, gentlemanly James Bond.
Quiller soft-pedals; back-pedals; acquiesces; plays everything low-key. But inside his pulse is racing and he’s considering every possible escape-route. He’s not thinking about his next Scotch, or his next Benson&Hedges. He’s thinking about the mission, always the mission, 100% the mission.
After a long car chase, three scummy Algerian thugs have forced him off the road and now he stands with his butt leant up against the bonnet of his rent-a-car; while they taunt him. They want answers and they’re going to extract them roughly.
James Bond would light a cigarette and smoke it, indifferent to his captors. Bond doesn’t waste words on small-fry.
What does Quiller do? Three filthy Algerian hoods are smirking at him, laughing at him, spluttering Arabic expletives on him.
Okay. They toy with him, he is allowed a cigarette. But he palms the lit match. He’s been waiting for this. He incinerate the three enemies with that little match.
The writing of Elleston Trevor which conveys this is just outlandish. Nothing like it in Fleming; nothing like it anywhere that I’ve ever seen.
Quiller is c-r-a-z-y. He doesn’t carry a gun. He truly doesn’t need one. He watches everything and watched everyone around him and he knows all the time, exactly what’s going on.
Best fiction agent ever.
September 14th, 2021 at 3:13 pm
Harold Pinter wrote the screenplay,and you can definitely see some pinteresque touches within the movie, especially in the character played by Senta Berger. Although I thought her performance wasn’t up to par with that of Segal, Guinness, and Von Sydow, who I thought were all excellent.
February 16th, 2022 at 8:22 pm
[…] reading Michael Shonk’s recent review of the Quiller novel The Tango Briefing, along with the episode of the TV series based on it, I […]
February 16th, 2022 at 9:32 pm
[…] QUILLER. “The Price of Violence.†BBC, 60 minutes. 29 August 1975. (Season 1, Episode 1.) Michael Jayston (Quiller), Moray Watson (Angus Kinloch). Guest Cast: Sinéad Cusack, Ed Bishop. Screenplay: Michael J. Bird, based on the character created by Adam Hall (Elleston Trevor). Director: Peter Graham Scott. Currently available on YouTube. […]