Sun 1 Apr 2018
MIKE NEVINS on More Early Inspector Maigret Stories, Part Two.
Posted by Steve under Authors , Columns , Reviews[11] Comments
by Francis M. Nevins
At the end of last month’s column we saw Simenon becoming a bit uncomfortable with having retired Maigret and deprived him of official status. His next published case, “L’Etoile du Nord” (Police-Film/Police Roman, 30 September 1938), takes place two or three days before he’s due to retire and features, of all people, Sergeant Lucas, who according to “Mademoiselle Berthe et son Amant,” published less than six months earlier, was killed beside him.
Madame Maigret is already in Meung-sur-Loire, preparing their new home, and the Commissaire has spent the night cleaning out his office in the Quai des Orfèvres. Around dawn he hears the phone ringing in the office next to his, picks up the receiver and quickly finds himself going out in the rain and gloom to investigate a murder in the titular establishment, one of those “drab fourth-rate hotels” to be found near every major train station, in this case the Gare du Nord.
The victim is Georges Bompard, a fortyish womanizer who rented a room from the hotel’s night porter around 3:30 A.M., two hours before someone entered the room (which apparently wasn’t locked) and stabbed him in the back. Prime suspect is a self-proclaimed prostitute in her late teens who claims to have picked up Bompard in the street and rented her own room in the Etoile du Nord shortly before her customer rented his. Maigret takes her back to Headquarters where there begins a tense confrontational interrogation of the young hooker, complete with seamy sexual stuff—the kid is made to stand naked with other whores picked up during the night—but also with clues of the sort we might expect to find in, say, the cross-examination of a hostile witness by Perry Mason.
The story never appeared in EQMM—obviously because too many elements, including a botched abortion crucial to the plot, were not to Fred Dannay’s taste—and as far as I know its only appearance in English was in MAIGRET’S PIPE. Too bad. It’s one of the most intellectually challenging of the shorter Maigrets, and one could almost say that Simenon permits the astute reader to figure out the truth by pure reasoning.
With “L’Auberge aux Noyés” (Police-Film/Police-Roman, 11 November 1938) Maigret is back in harness as if he’d never retired, although he’s not at the Quai des Orfèvres but in the town of Nemours on a business visit to the local captain of gendarmerie. A savage storm comes up and he spends the night at the house of Captain Tillemont, who receives a phone call at 6:00 A.M.—another of those damn early-morning phone calls!—and invites the Commissaire to accompany him to the site of a “curious accident” where the highway between Nemours and Montargis parallels the banks of the river Loing.
There’s a curve in the road 700 meters from the Auberge des Pecheurs, which means the Fishermen’s Inn but is locally known as the Inn of the Drowned (the story’s French title) because of several fatal accidents at the curve. Now there seems to have been another. “A ten-ton lorry, one of those stinking monsters that travel by day and by night along main roads,” has hit a car stalled at the curve with its lights off. The car went over the bank into the swollen Loing but no one knows what happened to the young couple who were apparently inside.
When the auto is pulled out of the water, somehow the door of the luggage compartment comes open and reveals the body of a middle-aged woman, her throat cut by a razor. With the Auberge aux Noyés as his headquarters Maigret takes an unofficial hand in the investigation and soon finds reason to believe that things aren’t what they seem. That evening, under weather conditions equally miserable, he sets up a reconstruction of the event as only he can.
It’s an excellent story, perhaps more cerebral than emotional, although there are too many unseen but crucial characters and too much happens too quickly at the climax. I wish Simenon had taken a few thousand extra words for this one, which appeared in EQMM for January 1975 as “The Inn of the Drowned” and in MAIGRET’S PIPE as “The Drowned Men’s Inn.”
Perhaps the most popular of the Maigret short stories, at least in this country, is “Stan-le-Tueur” (Police-Roman, 23 December 1938). It’s the earliest short Maigret to appear in English, translated by Anthony Boucher (EQMM, September 1949), and was collected both in THE SHORT CASES OF INSPECTOR MAIGRET (1959, Boucher’s translation) and in MAIGRET’S PIPE (1977, translated by Jean Stewart). Its title all three times was “Stan the Killer,” a literal translation of the French title.
Simenon opens with Maigret and his men—including once again the supposedly deceased Sergeant Lucas—having staked out a shabby hotel which is being used as a hideout by between four and eight Polish criminals, a ruthless gang responsible for raids on several farmhouses and the slaughter of everyone inside including children. The gangsters are known only by the colorful nicknames the police have given them—the Beard, One-Eye, Spinach, the Fat Boy—and their leader, known as Stan the Killer, has sent a note to Maigret threatening to shoot down any number of innocent bystanders if an arrest is attempted.
Into this powder keg steps Michel Ozep, a former Polish army officer with nothing to live for, who comes to Maigret and offers in effect to commit suicide by cop, taking Stan out in order to prevent bloodshed even if it means his own life. At the climax Maigret sends Ozep into the Hôtel Beauséjour to confront the young Polish woman who runs with the gang, and the results are violent and tragic.
In some respects the two English translations of this story differ wildly, and we must try to account for the differences. In Boucher’s version Maigret from a hotel room across the street from the gang’s hideout observes the young woman “dusting the frame of a bright-colored picture on the wall.” On entering the room he discovers that the picture is a portrait of the woman herself, who’s lying on the floor with her throat cut. He pulls down the picture and finds from the lettering on the back that it’s an illustration accompanying an article entitled “The Pretty Pole and the Terror of Terre Haute” from the American true crime magazine Real Life Detective Cases.
Except for the woman’s throat being cut, there’s not a word of this in Jean Stewart’s later translation. Did Stewart omit it or did Boucher invent it? I strongly suspect the latter. As we’ve seen in earlier columns, Boucher did have a tendency to translate very freely at times. Besides, the American details suggest Boucher because they seem to ring true—and also to be way beyond Simenon, who in the Thirties knew less than nothing about the U.S., so much so that in the Stewart version (and presumably the French original) Maigret and Lucas “drew aside the [dead] woman’s dress and uncovered white flesh on which was the mark with which, in America, they brand criminal women.”
From what benighted source did Simenon unearth that tidbit? And should we be surprised that Boucher thought it necessary to get rid of it and substitute his own account of how the French police learned of the woman’s American criminal background?
Within less than a year of the story’s appearance in EQMM it became the basis of a 60-minute live TV drama (THE TRAP, CBS, 20 May 1950), starring E.G. Marshall and Herbert Berghof, although which actor played Maigret seems to be lost to history. A little more than two years later the story was recycled for CBS’ STUDIO ONE SUMMER THEATER (1 September 1952), this time with Romney Brent and Eli Wallach in the leading roles although once again we don’t know which man played Maigret. Paul Nickell directed from a teleplay by Paul Monash, whose script was likely used also in the version seen on THE TRAP considering that the adaptations were broadcast on the same network so close together. In view of the infant medium’s infantile restrictions I find it hard to believe that either TV version came close to doing justice to Simenon’s story.
In “La Vieille Dame de Bayeux” (Police-Roman, 3 February 1939) we find Maigret transferred to Normandy and based temporarily in Caen, where he’s been assigned to reorganize the Brigade Mobile, the French counterpart of England’s Flying Squad. There he’s visited by 28-year-old Mlle. Cécile Ledru, the paid companion to wealthy widow Joséphine Croizier, with whom Cécile lives in Bayeux, a half-hour from Caen.
While on a visit to Caen for dental work and staying in the palatial home of her nephew and heir Philippe Deligeard, the older woman suffered a fatal heart attack. More than one doctor has certified the nature of Joséphine’s death but Cécile is convinced that her benefactress was murdered and insists that Maigret investigate. The result is a fascinating but almost completely cerebral story, so arranged that most readers will be able to figure out the gist of the plot but can’t possibly know the details until Simenon reveals them.
This story too was translated twice, by Boucher for EQMM (August 1952) and the SHORT CASES collection and by Jean Stewart for MAIGRET’S PIPE, the title all three times being “The Old Lady of Bayeux.” Once again there are differences between the translations but they’re not as consequential as those between the two versions of “Stan the Killer.”
According to Boucher, Cécile tells Maigret: “I was an orphan, and I started out in life, at the age of fifteen, as a maid of all work. I was still wearing pigtails, and I didn’t know how to read or write.” Stewart renders this passage: “I was an orphan, and my first job was as a maid of all work. I was only fifteen, with my hair still down my back, and I couldn’t read or write….”
Close enough, yes? The other variations are no more important than this one. The strangest detail in the story is common to both translations and therefore almost certainly Simenon’s: Cécile tells Maigret that she knows she takes nothing under Mme. Croizier’s will because “I drew up the will myself….” Neat trick for someone who isn’t a notaire!
This story too was adapted for live TV in the medium’s infant years. “The Old Lady of Bayeux” (SUSPENSE, CBS, 2 September 1952, 30 minutes) was directed by Robert Stevens from a teleplay by Halsted Welles. This time we know who played Maigret. It was Mexican-born Luis Van Rooten (1906-1973), one of the best known actors of radio’s golden age, who indeed appeared on THE ADVENTURES OF ELLERY QUEEN and was the subject of an encomium by Queen co-creator and radio supervisor Manfred B. Lee.
In a letter of 1 August 1946 to Tony Boucher, who was collaborating with Manny on Queen scripts while also translating Simenon, Jorge Luis Borges and others for EQMM, Manny called Van Rooten “a little bald-headed guy who for my money is one of the great radio actors….A terrific performer. You simply can’t believe that a voice like that can come from a guy so small.”
Anyone who’d like to travel back in time and see Van Rooten playing Maigret is in rare luck: this particular episode of SUSPENSE happens to be accessible on YouTube. Featured in the cast are Edgar Stehli (Philippe Deligeard) and Nicole Stéphan (Cécile). There’s more suspense in the SUSPENSE version than in Simenon’s story, but for my money Van Rooten with his bald pate and neat little mustache evokes Poirot rather than the heavy-set titan of the Quai des Orfèvres.
The last Maigret story to be written and published before the outbreak of World War II was “L’Amoureux de Madame Maigret (Police-Roman, 28 July 1939), which appeared in EQMM (“The Stronger Vessel,” January 1952, translated by Boucher) but didn’t show up in a collection until MAIGRET’S PIPE (1977, translated by Jean Stewart).
Here but to the best of my knowledge in no other novel or story, the Maigrets’ home is an apartment in the Place de Vosges, where Simenon and his first wife in fact lived from 1924 until the early Thirties. Madame Maigret notices a strange old man in a dandified outfit sitting motionless in the park below her window for hours on end and mentions the matter to her husband, who playfully suggests she has an admirer (the amoureux of the title).
One summer evening Maigret goes down to talk to the old man and finds him shot to death, apparently from a window of the apartment house looking down on the park. It quickly becomes apparent that the “old dandy” was a young man wearing a wig and false mustache, but why he spent hours every day sitting on that park bench remains a mystery.
Then one of Maigret’s neighbors reports that his maid has vanished, along with his wife’s jewelry. Madame Maigret herself takes something of a hand in the investigation, which establishes that the two matters are of course connected, but the denouement reveals a spy vs. spy intrigue with the countries carefully unspecified, appropriate for the time but not very exciting, and Maigret is ordered to drop the case.
As Fred Dannay pointed out in his introduction to the EQMM translation, the first English-language title is based on a Biblical verse (“giving honour unto the wife as unto the weaker vessel,” 1 Peter iii, 7). Almost certainly the title came from Boucher, who knew his Bible well.
As with some of the earlier tales in the series, comparison of the two translations yields some interesting results. In Boucher’s version, examination of the murdered man’s clothes reveals “a sizable quantity of very fine flour—not pure, but mixed with traces of bran….” The bran indicates a mill rather than a bakery, but what would the dead man be doing in a mill?
The question is answered at the end when, in Boucher’s words, we learn that he lived “at Corbeil, near the mills.” Jean Stewart bungles the translation when she locates the man’s home “at Corbeil, near Moulins….” Moulin means mill, but if the French word refers to a place not a physical mill, the flour-and-bran dust in the dead man’s clothes remains unaccounted for.
“L’Amoureux” was the last story in which Maigret appeared for almost three years. He was next seen in MAIGRET REVIENT, a volume consisting of three new novels, published by Gallimard in 1942 but written during the earlier years of war and ocupation: LES CAVES DU MAJESTIC late in 1939, LE MAISON DU JUGE and CÉCILE EST MORTE in 1940. In 1944, still under Nazi occupation, Gallimard published another omnibus of original novels, SIGNÉ PICPUS, which consisted of the title book (written in 1941) plus FÉLICIE EST LA (from May 1942) and L’INSPECTEUR CADAVRE (from March 1943), plus an assortment of non-series short stories dating from 1937-38.
The same year saw publication by Gallimard of LES NOUVELLES ENQUÊTES DE MAIGRET, which brought together all the short stories discussed here and in earlier columns. Three new Maigret shorts, including one never officially translated into English, also came out during the dark years.
These works, all of which seem to have embodied Simenon’s “contract with France” to say not a word hinting that the country was under German control, are best discussed in another column at another time. This one is far too long already.
April 1st, 2018 at 8:36 pm
Distraction that it might be, I have to tell you all what I know about Luis Van Rooten.
He was, of course, a superb character actor, with credits in feature films, radio, and TV all through the ’50s and ’60s.
Van Rooten played Maigret, Vidocq – and also Knobby Walsh (in the short-lived Joe Palooka TV series).
I think most of the readers here might recall his brief but significant appearance in “The Case Of The One-Eyed Witness”, during Season One of Perry Mason (he doesn’t play the title role).
You can find his numerous credits at IMDb, should you be interested.
That said, I’d like to tell you about where I first knew about Luis d’Antin Van Rooten: as a brilliantly funny writer.
Late in his life, Van Rooten wrote several brief volumes of some of the most adroit wordplay I’ve ever had the pleasure of reading.
A brief biblography:
– Mots D’Heueres: Gousses, Rames, a clever rewrite of Mother Goose rhymes in phonetic French; Best read aloud by someone who knows the language, with extensive footnotes faithfully translating the fractured Francais.
– Van Rooten’s Book Of Improbable Saints: an irreverent hagiography: Lives of some saints you probably never heard of; I’m guessing that Luis Van Rooten was at least an observant Catholic, since he has the style of such books down pat. Anyway, the wordplay here is all in English, so you won’t need an interpreter.
– The Floriculturist’s Vade Mecum of Exotic and Recondite Plants, Shrubs and Grasses, and One Malignant Parasite (and don’t think I didn’t have a time getting all that down here).
Van Rooten was deeply interested in floriculture, which makes his humor here all the more cutting (sorry – couldn’t resist).
Luis Van Rooten died in 1973; I believe that the second and third books here were published posthumously.
No matter; all three books deserve to be read and laughed with, and I welcome this opportunity/excuse to bring them to your attention.
April 2nd, 2018 at 12:22 am
I know Luis Van Rooten from all the radio he did that I’ve been able to listen to, but I never knew what he looked like. I suppose I’ve seen his many many times before, but until I watched the first 10minutes of that SUSPENSE video was able to watch him and know who he was at the same time.
For what it’s worth, he’s not at all what I think Inspector Maigret looks like.
Thanks, Mike, for all that information. Nicely done!
April 2nd, 2018 at 11:57 am
Not a fan of Maigret so I am unqualified to judge the actors who have played him, but who is the one considered best?
The new Maigret version on PBS and the streaming service BritBox starring the Rowan Atkinson have not been bad. The cast is too English and it lacks a French feel, but Atkinson is good as a dramatic actor.
I watched the first and found the story too focused on the psychology of the detective and the pressures he feels as innocent women continued to get murdered like plot devices.
If I had to pick a favorite Maigret I would turn to Michael Gambon. If my eyes could handle subtitles I would like to see the Bruno Cremer version. It is surprising how many Maigret adaptations can be found on YouTube.
April 2nd, 2018 at 4:50 pm
As for actors playing Maigret the best include Cremar, Jean Gabin, Rupert Davies, Charles Laughton, and Gambon. Surely the worst are Richard Harris and Rowan Atkinson neither of who even vaguely suggest Maigret, but if I had to choose just one it would be the stocky world weary Gabin from the fifties French Maigret’s.
I can’t confirm it now, but the only reference I recall seeing on the Wallachia episode listed him as Stan, though he would have been well suited to either role.
April 2nd, 2018 at 5:02 pm
After Gabin I would go with harry Baur in Julien Duvivier’s The Head of A Man.
April 2nd, 2018 at 10:18 pm
My favorite is Bruno Cremer. I have all 54 of the French episodes on dvd and they are fairly faithful to the novels. Cremer became famous for his version of Maigret during 1991 to 2005. He liked smoking cigars but it led to his death from cancer of the tongue. The series was so popular that he could have continued playing Maigret for much longer.
April 3rd, 2018 at 8:25 pm
Barry,
Thanks, I let Baur slip and he was very good, fine actor and fine Maigret.
Walker,
Cremar was perfect, but I have a sentimental connection to Gabin.
There was a German actor who played Maigret in the sixties and was popular, but always seemed too jolly and slight for the role. I probably saw more of his Maigret’s than anyone save Cremar and Gambon. As I recall he was quite beloved in Europe for playing Maigret.
When the statue of Maigret was unveiled there were a dozen of Maigret’s present from all over Europe for the event along with Simenon who also dressed the part.
April 3rd, 2018 at 9:13 pm
There was a Belgian TV series called MAIGRET that ran from 1964 to 1968. It starred Jan Teulings (12 eps) and Kees Brusse (six eps) as the title character. Might this be the one you remember?
April 10th, 2018 at 4:00 pm
Now that the Rowan Atkinson Maigret will be airing on PBS this week in this area I am looking forward to it to see if he’s as bad as a couple of you say he is. I have a reputation for being able to enjoy things that no one else does.
April 15th, 2018 at 6:58 pm
I’ve now seen Rowan Atkinson in “Maigret Sets a Trap” on PBS and enjoyed it. I’d not read the book so the ending came as a surprise.
July 20th, 2018 at 10:40 am
Belatedly:
I was looking at an illustrated survey of the genre (The Murder Book, by Tage la Cour and Harald Mogenson, from 1971).
There’s a sizable segment devoted to Georges Simenon and Maigret; included is a group shot of Simenon posing with four TV Maigrets from all over Europe.
The Italian and Dutch actors aren’t identified; Simenon is standing between England’s Rupert Davies and Germany’s Heinz Ruehmann, who I’ll guess is the guy David Vineyard is referring to in his comment.
Simenon and the Maigrets are at the unveiling of a statue of the Inspector in the Netherlands; all are apparently enjoying the festivities.
The actors – and Simenon – are all dressed for the part: hats, pipes, trenchcoats, umbrellas … it looks to have been a good time for all.