Mon 8 Apr 2019
Pulp Stories I’m Reading, Selected by David Vineyard: JUDSON P. PHILIPS “Men About to Die.”
Posted by Steve under Pulp Fiction , Stories I'm Reading[11] Comments
JUDSON P. PHILIPS “Men About to Die.” Novella. Park Avenue Hunt Club #11. First published in Detective Fiction Weekly, February 2, 1935. Never reprinted. See comments #’s 1 and 2 for reprint information.
Running in the pages of Detective Fiction Weekly, where it vied for readers’ attention with the likes of Erle Stanley Gardner’s Lester Leith, Richard Sale’s Daffy Dill, and Carroll John Daly’s Satan Hall, the popular Park Avenue Hunt Club was an American version of Edgar Wallace’s Just Men, a team of vigilantes battling crime in the age of the Depression, gangsters. John Dillinger, and Bonny and Clyde.
The Club members were handsome former secret agent Geoffrey Saville; big game hunter and red haired giant John Jericho; and chess master and medical student Arthur Hallam, who, their identities known only to Inspector James Emory Doane NYPD, wage a violent and bloody war on the underworld of New York.
Pretty standard pulp stuff it sounds and it was, but behind the name Judson P. Philips was Hugh Pentecost, one of the longest lived writers to emerge from the pulps and who, like relatively few others, had a healthy critically successful career as a mid-list author under his own name and as Philips, and whose many series included the popular hotel manager Pierre Chambrun and freelance journalist Peter Styles series as well as one featuring John Jericho, an artist who shares with the Hunt Club Jericho mostly only his size and red hair.
Like most of the writers who survived the pulps and thrived, Pentecost not only outgrew his origins, he expanded his horizons so that the Peter Styles books had a serious social conscience tackling major issues of the day, while Jericho’s adventures featured a deeply humanitarian sleuth often rescuing victims of society. Save for retaining a gift for plot, suspense, and action they and Chambrun are a far cry from the bloodthirsty Park Avenue Hunt Club.
The dangerous Dzamba brothers, Leonardo, Salvatore, and Vincente (no, they aren’t mutant ninja turtles) are on trial in a case brought by none other than Inspector Doane and prosecutor John Crowther, and a witness has warned Doane that the Dzambas plan a spectacular escape during the trial, so he calls on Saville, Jericho, and Hallam to be present when the bloodshed begins. The Club has a history with the Dzambas, Jericho himself having killed brother Angelo with his bare hands.
And sure enough something goes wrong, the judge is murdered in chambers, four policeman are killed in a bloody shootoutmand the Dzambas are on the loose. The Park Avenue Hunt Club is on the prowl, turning to a crooked former cop who helped the Dzamba brothers in the past but Salvatore gets to him before the boys can.
With the Dzambas out for revenge, and even their own lawyer murdered by them, the one target left is prosecutor Crowther, who lives in the country with his young wife. Local yokels can hardly be expected to protect him, so it looks like a job for the boys.
No detection here, it’s mostly an action piece closer to the hero pulps and they’re figures of justice than sleuths, but it is satisfyingly fast paced, and despite a plethora of characters in a relatively short piece. it works well enough.
This is a single contained story, though some of the Park Avenue tales were serials and likely a bit less rushed, if still as plot and action heavy. You can see why this series was popular and featured so often on covers of the magazine. It’s pure pulp, full of movement, setbacks, and a big finale with the three heroes once again emerging triumphant in their secret war against crime, and in a relatively few years Pentecost would be moving on to a long successful career.
April 8th, 2019 at 9:11 pm
It turns out that Arthur Hallum, one of the three members of the Park Avenue Hunt Club, also shows up later as the narrator of the non-pulp John Jericho stories.
Here’s a link to my review of THE GIRL WITH SIX FINGERS, by Hugh Pentecost, in which I also talk a little about the earlier Park Avenue Hunt Club stories:
https://mysteryfile.com/blog/?p=45522
April 9th, 2019 at 7:34 am
One correction: This story has been reprinted once — in THE COMPLETE ADVENTURES OF THE PARK AVENUE HUNT CLUB, VOLUME 1 (of 2) from George A. Vanderburgh’s Battered Silicon Dispatch Box (2006), #11 in the “Lost Treasures from the Pulps” series, published in folio hardcover.
April 9th, 2019 at 8:13 am
Steve – It just so happens that that particular issue of DFW was uploaded to Archive.org (The Internet Archive) several weeks ago. Philips’s story is here:
https://archive.org/details/DetectiveFictionWeeklyV091N0119350202jvhMkaVsEric/page/n7
April 9th, 2019 at 10:22 am
Jerry and Mike
This is exactly the kind of information I love being corrected about. Thanks, guys!
April 9th, 2019 at 9:21 am
The Park Avenue Hunt Club concept is right in my wheel house, reminiscent of The Four Just Men. And politics absolutely not aside.
April 9th, 2019 at 6:00 pm
Wallace’s Just Men spawned several of these teams of crime fighters, amateur and official, including the Five Kings of early Leslie Charteris tales (the Saint was the Joker), the Secret Six, and the Suicide Squad. The Hunt Club was one of the most successful of these teams.
Pentecost handles the action quite well, orchestrating the trio through better than average adventures.
Over the years reprints weer few and far between until the expensive Battered Silicon Dispatch Box editions to the extent I wondered if Pentecost himself might have discouraged his pulp work being reprinted.
April 13th, 2019 at 10:29 am
Steve and David – A subsequent issue of DFW also featured the next Park Avenue Hunt Club story after “Men About to Die”:
https://archive.org/details/DetectiveFictionWeeklyV091N0419350223/page/n5
April 13th, 2019 at 2:23 pm
Thanks, Mike. There are a lot more pulp stories online than I’ve been aware of, till now.
April 15th, 2019 at 11:46 am
I can say, with pride, that I provided ALL the pulp issues used to print The Park Ave. Hunt Club books. Just tooting my own horn.
April 17th, 2019 at 8:16 pm
Toot away, Sheila. We need more contributors like you.
March 20th, 2020 at 10:14 pm
It was years ago, forgot the title, but remember it appeared as a Hugh Pentecost story and the theme was roughly: “I generously forgive you your treachery at Auschwitz, and to celebrate our new friendship, how’s about a totally innocent game of correspondence chess … eh? eh? eh?”