Fri 29 Nov 2019
Pulp PI Stories I’m Reading: VINCENT STARRETT “The Taggart Assignment.”
Posted by Steve under Pulp Fiction , Stories I'm Reading[2] Comments
VINCENT STARRETT “The Taggart Assignment.” Short story. Jimmy Lavender #6. First published in Short Stories, 10 August 1922. Reprinted in The Detective Megapack: 28 Tales by Modern and Classic Authors (Wildside Press, Kindle edition, January 2016).
Although a number of his Jimmy Lavender stories were collected in book form during Vincent Starrett’s lifetime, this doesn’t doesn’t seem to have been one of them, and I think there may have been a reason for it. Before getting into that, however, let me say first of all that the resemblance of the Lavender tales to Conan Doyle’s stories about Sherlock Holmes is unmistakable. (Starrett was a noted Sherlockian of his day.)
Simply move the stories from London in the late 1800s to Chicago in he 1920s, swap Watson for a narrator-assistant named “Gilly†Gilruth, and there you have it. Even the story itself, that of a young woman whose fiancé has gone missing only days before their wedding, is reminiscent of one of Holmes’s own adventures, that being “A Case of Identity.”
The about-to-be-jilted woman — or has something more serious happened to the missing man? — wishes no publicity, and Lavender agrees. The trail leads, by sheer coincidence (Lavender thinks not) to a another missing man, this one the circulation manager of a local newspaper.
The story is lively and fun to read, with Gilly more actively involved that Watson was, but (and I hate to have to say thus) it’s seriously marred by a final conclusive clue that unfortunately means nothing to the reader and everything to Jimmy Lavender. I was somewhat mollified by a very striking last line, however.
November 29th, 2019 at 9:19 pm
I enjoyed the Lavender stories, especially when he made use of 20’s Chicago as the setting for the stories. The first one I read was actually set in a speakeasy, but certainly the Holmes imitation is there, just carefully repackaged in a livelier American setting, Sherlock Holmes with the occasional chatter of a tommy-gun.
November 30th, 2019 at 2:55 pm
I have at least one collection of Jimmy Lavender stories in book form, but I’ve never gotten around to reading it. Even though I thought this particular story was flawed, from a “fair play” point of view, I enjoyed enough o seek out more.