Fri 10 Dec 2021
Diary Review: ELLERY QUEEN’S MYSTERY MAGAZINE – February 1967.
Posted by Steve under Diary Reviews , Magazines[5] Comments
ELLERY QUEEN’S MYSTERY MAGAZINE – February 1967. Overall rating: 3½ stars.
STANLEY ELLIN “The Twelfth Statue.†Short novel. A movie producer noted for his quickie productions and his weakness for young girls disappears from his closed-off Italian movie set. The location of his body seems to be obvious halfway through, but Ellin still has some twists left, in addition to masterful background. (5)
JANE SPEED “Fair’s Fair.†A child’s view of murder, that of a man who killed a cat. (4)
CHARLES B. CHILD “A Quality of Mercy. Reprinted from Collier’s, 11 March 1950. Inspector Chafik solves the murder of a blackmailer, but destroys the incriminating etter. Excellent background an characterization. (4)
ROBERT L. FISH “The Adventure of the Perforated Ulster.†Schlock Homes breaks up a plot by a trading stamp company to destroy confidence in British clubs. Hilarious. (5)
JUDITH O’NEILL “The Identification.†First story. Woman betrays rebel organizer. Awkward beginning. (2)
R. BRETNOR “Specimen of the Week.†Anthropological species turns on guardian.. (1)
S. K. SNEDEGAR “Charles H. Goren Solves a Bridge Murder.†Too bad I don’t know anything about bridge, but story was poor anyway. (0)
VINCENT McCONNOR “The Man Who Collected Obits.†Man who works in a newspaper morgue discovers weird coincidence in the daily obituaries. (3)
PATRICIA HIGHSMITH “Camera Fiend.” Reprinted from Cosmopolitan, September 1960, as “Camera Finish.†A not-so-bright murderer allows his picture to be taken with his victim. (3)
ARTHUR PORGES “The Scientist and the Multiple Murder.†Eight men are electrocuted in s rooftop pool. Seems contrived. (3)
MARGERY SHARP “Driving Home.†Reprinted from Good Housekeeping, August 1956. Man needs wife’s alibi and thus saves their marriage. Too much soppy writing. (2)
LAWRENCE TREAT “F As in Frame-Up.†A spendthrift husband is framed for murder involving theft of necklace. Lieutenant Decker’s hunch plays off. (4)
December 10th, 2021 at 9:01 pm
An excellent issue with outstanding contributors.
A word here calling out Child’s Chafik stories, an attractive character with a colorful background and too neglected today.
Ellin contributes his usual fine work. He didn’t falter often in novel form and virtually never in shorter form.
Treat was usually in fine form in EQMM, while I generally liked Bretnor and McConner.
December 10th, 2021 at 10:43 pm
There were what I felt some duds in this issue, but in many ways, it was an All Star issue, what with all of the names you mention, plus Robert L. Fish and Patricia Highsmith too.
December 10th, 2021 at 11:00 pm
Nitpick:
Robert Fish’s story was “The Adventure Of The Perforated Ulster“, a typical Schlock Homes pun.
I’ll attribute this to Runaway SpellCheck, which doesn’t recognize wordplay.
December 10th, 2021 at 11:11 pm
That’s kind of you to come up with a ready-made excuse for me, but in this case the glitch occurred somewhere between my eyes, which saw Ulster, and my fingers, which typed Ulcer.
I don’t know what to do about that, except rely on folks like you. It’s fixed now, and Thanks!
December 12th, 2021 at 11:09 am
I looked up my copy of EQMM with this story and just finished reading it. “Masterful background” indeed! One of the better recreations of the problems connected with the making of B-movies or low budget films. I think I’ll watch I, Claudius again. Many Roman emperors were crazy as hell.