Mon 9 May 2022
Pulp PI Stories I’m Reading: RAOUL WHITFIELD “China Man.â€
Posted by Steve under Pulp Fiction , Stories I'm Reading[3] Comments
RAOUL WHITFIELD “China Man.†Jo Gar #18. Published under the name Ramon Decolta in Black Mask, March 1932. Reprinted in The Hardboiled Dicks, edited by Ron Goulart (Sherbourne Press, 1965). Collected in West of Guam: The Complete Cases of Jo Gar (Altus Press, 2013).
Jo Gar is attacked in his office by someone who appears to be a Chinese coolie, but strangely enough the knife thrower misses his mark, even at close range. Gar tries to follow him, but loses him in the crowds in the streets of Manila under the stress of an approaching hurricane.
Returning to his small cramped office, he finds a note from his client slipped under the door. The man, an importer of valuable jade, had come early and left. The note accuses a “China man†as the person who has been stealing from him.
Then his client turns up murdered, knifed to death, and his body dumped into a river.
This may sound like a complicated case, but in spite of what also seems like a story with a lot of action, neither is true. What makes the story work as well as it does is the setting, that of what had to have been a really exotic, foreign land to most readers of Black Mask in 1932, the streets and other sights of the Philippines. And to tell you the truth, it probably still is to most people living in the US today.
Note: I first wrote a review of this story in 1967, and I posted it on this blog a few weeks ago. Follow the link and you can read it here.
May 9th, 2022 at 8:33 pm
The Gar stories always struck me as perfect for Hollywood with the mix of exotic settings and action.
They aren’t Whitfield’s best works, but they are my favorite and that’s saying a lot because I hold DEATH IN A BOWL and GREEN ICE only just below Hammett and Chandler and even have great affection for the Temple Field novels.
Like the previous Nebel post I’ll point out that the best loved and admired of the Gar stories tend to run longer than this supporting a long held prejudice I have that the novella may be the ideal length for most genre fiction when done right.
May 10th, 2022 at 6:04 am
To me, the “West of Guam†collected Jo Gar stories, read start to finish, is as good as anything in the hardboiled crime genre. As good as the continental op (yeah I guess that’s redundant). Also felt like ‘Death in a Bowl’ had the same voice as the jo gar stories. Which, rather than a criticism, I take as a major bonus.
May 11th, 2022 at 12:33 pm
I think Death in a Bowl is a classic, even better than the Jo Gar stories, as good as they are.