Wed 13 Jul 2022
Diary Review: ELLERY QUEEN’S MYSTERY MAGAZINE, March 1967.
Posted by Steve under Diary Reviews , Magazines[14] Comments
ELLERY QUEEN’S MYSTERY MAGAZINE, March 1967. Overall rating: **½
JAMES YAFFE “Mom and the Haunted Mink.” OK, if played a a game to trick the reader. But the police detective telling the story to his mother must certainly have recognized the name-switch at once. Pfui. (0)
AGATHA CHRISTIE “Miss Marple and the Golden Galleon.” Original title: “Ingots of Gold.” [The Royal Magazine, February 1928]. The theft of gold bullion is solved by knowing gardeners never work on Monday. (2)
DONALD E. WESTLAKE “The Sweetest Man in the World.” Another insurance company fraud, mixed with impersonation, embezzlement, and murder. (3)
CHARLOTTE PERKINS GILMAN “The Yellow Wallpaper.” [First appeared in New England Magazine, January 1892.] First published over 60 years ago; “a classic tale of horror.” A woman is driven insane by wallpaper. Not very effective. (2)
ELLERY QUEEN “The Adventure of Abraham Lincoln’s Clue.” [First appeared in MD, June 1965, as “Abraham Lincoln’s Clue.”] Items with the signatures of both Lincoln and Poe turn out to be forgeries, but the stamps are worth a fortune. (4)
RICHARD DEMING “The Jolly Jugglers, Retired.” Bank robbers take over restaurant. Obvious from beginning. (1)
JOSEPH MATHEWSON “A Stranger’s Tale.” The fresh wrinkle in this story of identical twins is the same old crease. (2)
HUGH PENTECOST “The Monster of Lakeview.” Uncle George’s dog is is stolen for laboratory and saved by a befriended man-child. (3)
MARGERY ALLINGHAM “Bubble Bath No. 3.” [First appeared in Argosy (UK), July 1956, as “Three Is a Lucky Number.”] Wife-killer is foiled in third attempt. (3)
FRANK SISK “The Strange Adventure of Charles Homer.” The estate Surcease Isle becomes Circe’s Isle, but Homer escapes. A weird fantasy. (3)
CHARLES DICKENS “The Pair of Gloves.” [First appeared in Household Words, September 14 1850, uncredited.] Primitive police procedure; gloves have nothing to do with murder. Of historical interest only. (0)
PRINCESS ZAWADSKY “Third Act Curtain.” An actor masquerades as a notorious killer. (3)
JOAN KAPP “Mystery, Movie Style.” A lady jewel thief scares off two others. A fun story. [The author’s only published crime story.] (5)
GEORGES SIMENON “Inspector Maigret Directs.” [First appeared in English in Argosy (UK) November 1961, as “Under the Hammer.”] Maigret puts all the characters in a murder-drama through their paces continuously until the culprit is revealed. ( 4)
WILLIAM BRITTAIN “Mr. Strang Gives a Lecture.” A high school clears a student framed for robbery. Not a very promising series start. (2)
July 13th, 2022 at 5:57 pm
Somewhat reductionist take on the Gilman! Can’t say I’ve read any of the others…does seem a slight issue of EQMM.
July 13th, 2022 at 6:16 pm
I noted that too, about my rating of the Gilman story. Nothing about it comes back to me now,but I never have been a fan of horror fiction, classic or not.
As for the overall rating for this particular issue, 2 /12 is a perfect middle score, out of five. Totally average in my mind, that is, even thought it was billed as a 28th anniversary all-star issue.
July 13th, 2022 at 5:59 pm
Did you often catch up with back issues a nearly a year later?
July 13th, 2022 at 6:20 pm
I was reading issues in order back then, but once you fall behind on a plan like that, it’s hard to catch up. Now, over 55 years later, impossible is the word that comes to mind.
July 13th, 2022 at 8:04 pm
Very slight issue for the time period. Some good reprints and good writers, but most of them I had read elsewhere even way back when I was 17.
July 13th, 2022 at 10:45 pm
I wouldn’t have picked it up. Never really cared for EQMM. Too dry. Too “sophisticated.” But I rarely missed an issue of Mike Shayne Mystery Magazine, The Saint or those trashy little digests like Two-Fisted Detective Stories. The plup content of those rocked my world. Not so EQMM
July 14th, 2022 at 12:53 am
I had almost complete runs of both THE SAINT and MIKE SHAYNE magazines, but I always felt cheated with the first since I’d read most of the Saint stories before. And of the latter, I generally read only the Shayne story and skimmed the rest of the magazine.
July 15th, 2022 at 8:03 am
The story “The Yellow Wallpaper” was done on the radio as a SUSPENSE show (I think) with Agnes Moorehead as the woman driven crazy by the wallpaper. Well done, but “one and done” as far as repeated listening goes.
July 16th, 2022 at 9:17 pm
I really liked the Yaffe, Christie and Brittain tales. Even the Pentecost was Ok.
July 18th, 2022 at 2:53 am
An important point about “The Yellow Wallpaper” is that it is based on Gilman’s own treatment for post-natal depression.
And in the comment on the Miss Marple story, “Monday” should be “Whit Monday”.
July 18th, 2022 at 9:05 am
Thanks, Jonathan. Whit Monday makes a whole lot more sense.
July 18th, 2022 at 10:01 am
Steve,
A “lot” more may be overstating it. It makes a whit more sense.
July 18th, 2022 at 12:21 pm
Gilman was what was called 100 years ago “a man of letters”. I.e. Someone who wrote a lot and well in all genres. Chesterton, Capek, Tagore etc. We now need a gender neutral term!
The Utopian novel Herland is tops.
Her poem An Obstacle is a delight.
Her economics nonfiction still has bite.
Her mystery novels Unpunished didn’t click with me. But I should reread it.
July 22nd, 2022 at 10:02 am
No post should have exactly 13 comments