Wed 15 Mar 2023
SF Diary Review: ASTOUNDING SCIENCE FICTION September 1948.
Posted by Steve under Diary Reviews , Magazines , Science Fiction & Fantasy[6] Comments
ASTOUNDING SCIENCE FICTION. September 1948. Editor: John W. Campbell, Jr. Cover artist: Chesley Bonestell. Overall rating: ***
GEORGE O. SMITH “The Catspaw.†Novella. Two people are given conflicting information about a possible space-drive in their dreams. Tom Barden is given knowledge of the necessary science; Edith Ward is warned by an opposing faction that the drive is unstable and dangerous. Are they guinea pigs? The plot line is cleverly worked out, but the scientific jargon can be skipped. (4)
PETER PHILLIPS “Dreams Are Sacred.†A sports writer is sent into the dreams of an overworked fantasy writer to bring him back to reality. Excellent except for lack of an effective ending. (4)
RENE LAFAYETTE “The Great Air Monopoly.†Novelette. Ole Doc Methuselah stops over on a planet where one man has control of the only drugs useful against hay fever, and the machinery to keep ragweed circulating. Not much of a story and indifferently told. (1)
MACK CHAPMAN LEA “The Gorgons.†The natives on an uncharted planet were friendly, but their mental screens came down at night. (3)
JOHN D. MacDONALD “Dance of a New World.†A recruiter for a projected colony and a dancer in a tavern on Venus go to that world together. (2)
ARTHUR C. CLARKE “Inheritance.†Realistic story of the first space probes, by a man and his son. Point not clear. (2)
March 15th, 2023 at 6:34 pm
By that time, “Rene Lafayette” was probably more focused on launching dianetics than on Doc Methuselah.
March 15th, 2023 at 7:04 pm
Never reprinted. Not once.
March 15th, 2023 at 6:37 pm
With that lineup it seems odd the Smith seems to be the best story.
March 15th, 2023 at 6:59 pm
The “best” story? Yes, maybe the one by Smith, but only if you agree with me.
But if the criterion for “best” is the one that was anthologized the most often, it would be the one by Phillips, believe it or not. I count nine different times. The one by Smith not at all, but its length (40 pages) would have something to do with that. It was reprinted later only in THE WORLDS OF GEORGE O, a collection of various stories he wrote.
March 17th, 2023 at 1:28 pm
The Phillips the only one I’ve read…
March 17th, 2023 at 3:24 pm
All in all, in spite of a few well-known authors, not a memorable bunch of stories. My 3-star rating for the issue overall, or “average,” is something I’m quite OK with.