Thu 21 Sep 2023
SF Diary Review: GALAXY SF – June 1967.
Posted by Steve under Diary Reviews , Magazines , Science Fiction & Fantasy[2] Comments
GALAXY SF – June 1967. Editor: Frederik Pohl. Cover artist: Gray Morrow. Overall rating: ***
POUL ANDERSON – To Outlive Eternity. Serial; part 1 of 2. See review following the July 1967 issue. [NOTE: Expanded in 1970 and published as the novel Tau Zero.]
GARY WRIGHT “Mirror of Ice.†More a sports story than SF, but an exciting account of a new form of bobsledding. (4)
R. A. LAFFERTY “Polity and Customs of the Camiroi.†Further investigation of politics, religion, and life on Camiroi. (3) [NOTE: This follows the story “Primary Education of the Camiroi” in the December 1966 issue.]
ROGER ZELAZNY “The Man Who Loved the Faioli.†The gravekeeper of the universe meets a comforter of those who are about to die. Wish I understood. (3) [NOTE: This story has been collected and anthologized many times.]
C. C. MACAPP “Spare That Tree.†Novelette. A detective tries to regain a stolen tree by disguising himself as a tree himself. Goes from bad to worse. (1)
JIM HARMON “Howling Day.†The advance publicity releases for an invasion of Earth are mistaken for scripts. (2)
LARRY NIVEN “The Adults.†Novella. An alien in search for a lost colony brings Earth the roots and seeds for the tree-of-life, but the discovery is no longer needed or wanted by mankind. The alien’s culture is brought out piecewise and sympathetically, and its death, while necessary, is also regrettable. However, the story is clumsily written, and even worse, poorly edited. Much too long [at 70 pages]; the ending is best. *** [NOTE: This story was expanded in 1973 and published as the novel The Protectors.]
CHARLES V. DeVET “Alien’s Bequest.†An alien invader was sent with the best wishes of another intelligent race. (3)
September 21st, 2023 at 9:54 pm
Most exceptional, Anderson and Zelazny probably the stand outs for me.
September 21st, 2023 at 10:21 pm
Yes, looking backward now, I may have been a little hard on the stories, but I agree. The only author’s name I don’t recognize is Gary Wright, but whose story I ranked to highest. Turns out he wrote only one SF novel and seven short stories, but most or all to the better magazines.s .