Wed 14 Oct 2026
My Top 10 PI Novels, by Tony Baer.
— One per author; private = no police detectives:
The Maltese Falcon
Long Goodbye
Galton Case
8th Circle (Ellin)
No Good from a Corpse (Brackett)
Solomon’s Vineyard (Latimer)
Death in a Bowl (Whitfield)
Last Good Kiss (Crumley)
Taste of Ashes (Browne)
I, the Jury
October 14th, 2026 at 1:58 pm
A couple of thoughts from me:
Strangely enough, my own Top Ten list would look very much like this one. Your opinion may vary, but as I suspect, not by much.
Of Tony’s top ten, I am pleased to say that I have read nine. The outlier, for me, is Howard Browne’s book, which I have in a slip-cased edition, but even though everyone I know (well, lots of people) has told me I have to read it, so far, I haven’t. It’s on my list, though!
What I really wish is that I were younger again, young enough that I have not read these yet. What a treat to have ahead of me!
October 16th, 2026 at 7:27 pm
Not far from my own list. The Bracket, No Good From a Corpse, is almost a pastiche of Chandler, but brilliant on its own. Ellin’s 8th Circle is underrated, a rare attempt to write an actual novel about a Private Eye.
October 17th, 2026 at 9:36 pm
The Brackett is well worth another read of it on my part. I thought the Ellin was a literary novel (whatever that means) about a private eye and the life he leads.
October 18th, 2026 at 12:23 pm
Quite a list you’ve made, Tony. Just a few comments on the above. I still think Farewell My Lovely is the better book by Chandler, but The Long Goodbye is one small half-step behind it. I can probably come up with a half dozen Macdonald as good as Galton but it would be splitting hairs. He’s just Great! I’ve read the Ellin book and enjoyed it very much, but I’d never put it on a Top 10. I haven’t read the Brackett as yet but it’s high up on my TBR pile.
Lastly, I don’t care for the Crumley book at all. Good writer but the P.I. is no one I could ever root for. He seems like too much of a low-life character. Wasn’t the Kiss in the books title just some whore he slept with? All else on the list I completely agree with. Now I’ll have to come up with books to replace the Ellin & Crumley.
October 18th, 2026 at 12:39 pm
As you say, Paul, the Crumley book may be the most controversial of Tony’s selections. I enjoyed it a lot when I first read it, back when it first came out, but I haven’t had any desire to read it again (nor anything else by Crumley). For whatever that’s worth!
October 18th, 2026 at 3:40 pm
Just a quick note on my above comment. I’d have to include a Rex Stout
Nero Wolfe title to my Top Ten. I’ve always said League Of Frightened Men is the best Wolfe mystery. (Among all the great Wolfes’).
October 18th, 2026 at 4:29 pm
A great choice. I love it, too. That’s a wonderful book.
October 18th, 2026 at 5:31 pm
Paul, I picked the crumley for how much it stuck with me. These don’t necessarily represent my most enjoyable pi reading experiences. (For example, I’d rank ‘I was Dora Suarez’ as possibly the strongest hardboiled cop novel of all time—but the book is so nauseating I could not bear the idea of reading it again). crumleys other pi is much more sympathetic (Milo milodragovich). For an alternate top 10 pi pick I’d suggest ‘sad song singing’ by Thomas dewey. The Ellin is an elliptical story that comes full circle. I’ve a weakness for that kind of geometric perfection.
October 18th, 2026 at 6:31 pm
I love the Rex stout books as well; my favorite is probably some buried Caesar.
October 19th, 2026 at 7:16 pm
A wildly varying list!
Hammett Red Harvest
Erle Stanley Gardner Fish or Cut Bait
Harmon Coxe – The Frightened Fiancée
Norbert Davis – The Mouse in the Mountain
Frances Crane – The Yellow Violet
Barnard Kendrick – The Whistling Hangman
Carroll John Daly – The Snarl of the Beast
Richard Ellington – Exit for a Dame
Wade Miller – Fatal Step
Eustace Hale Ball – The Voice on the Wire
October 20th, 2026 at 9:05 am
Thanks Mike! More to my TBR pile!
October 20th, 2026 at 7:02 pm
Yes, that’s quite an eclectic list, and very impressive. I’ve read five, maybe six, and enjoyed them. But the last one? Never heard of it. Will have to find a copy!
November 2nd, 2026 at 10:19 pm
These aren’t the classics Tony’s list are, but ten more off beat and worthy of reading if you haven’t.
Blues for a Prince Bart Spicer
Another Little Drink Peter Cheney
Stella E. V. Cunningham
Sabotage Cleve Adams
Dividend on Death Brett Halliday
Private Eye Henry Kane
One Man’s Muddle E. V. Quinn
Hell is a City William Ard
Murder in the East Carroll John Daly
Hand in Glove Rex Stout
A few classics, a few really alternative, and afew obscure.
November 3rd, 2026 at 10:40 am
Thanks David! My ulterior motive in issuing a list was in hopes of other folks directing me to more good ones I’d missed! Cheers!