Sat 24 Oct 2026
A 1001 Midnights Review: BRETT HALLIDAY – Counterfeit Wife.
Posted by Steve under Uncategorized[7] Comments
by Art Scott
BRETT HALLIDAY – Counterfeit Wife. ZiffDavis, hardcover, 1947. Reprinted in paperback a number of times.

Mike Shayne, the durable private eye from Miami, has hung in there for an unusually long career (in part with the aid of ghost writers — see the next entry). The appeal of the character seems rooted in the straightforward approach originally laid out by Halliday (Davis Dresser). Shayne is a tough, direct character, not tricked out with gimmicks, not given to guilt complexes or excessive philosophizing.
The stories are fairly complicated. with a fun complement of fights, shoot-outs, mobsters, and slinky dames. Add to that a loyal secretary (Lucy Hamilton), a wisecracking newshound (Tim Rourke), a sympathetic cop (Will Gentry), a nasty, stupid cop (Peter Painter), a lot of two-fisted drinking, and you have all the elements. Mike Shayne is the Generic Private Eye.
This crackling adventure from Shayne’s middle period (after the death of his wife, while he was shuttling his home base between New Orleans and Miami) starts with the big redhead about to board a late plane to New Orleans when a nervous man, desperate to get on the flight, gives Shayne two hundred-dollar bills for his ticket. A woman claiming to be the man’s wife shows up a bit too late to catch him. Curious, Shayne follows her to a roadhouse and buys her a few drinks.

The bar owner pulls a gun on Shayne, demanding to know where he got one of those big bills; he and the woman try to escape in her car, which is promptly wrecked. Tums out the money is counterfeit, there’s a dead kidnap victim in the trunk of the car, the cops want Shayne for the murder of the man who took his apartment … and the narrative barrels on from there.
Dresser’s nuts-and-bolts style isn’t particularly elegant, but it gets the job done. There’s one terrific action sequence in which Shayne, naked, armed only with a liquor bottle, manages an escape from the counterfeiters, who were about to take him for a ride. One of the best of the Shaynes, helped considerably by the absence of simpering, kidnap-prone Lucy Hamilton.
———
Reprinted with permission from 1001 Midnights, edited by Bill Pronzini & Marcia Muller and published by The Battered Silicon Dispatch Box, 2007. Copyright © 1986, 2007 by the
Pronzini-Muller Family Trust.
October 25th, 2026 at 2:40 am
My opinion of this and Shayne is higher by far, as is my opinion of the Halliday Shayne’s and some of the ghosted books. I disagree Shayne is “generic,” a term I save for say Pete McGrath or Johnny Liddell. Shayne has a number of distinctive traits including being the most successful tec in the Sam Spade tradition after Sam himself.
And, like Spade, Shayne is no mean detective in many entries, playing great detective more often than most fictional private eyes.
I can’t agree on Lucy Hamilton either, who evolves into a smart and pretty tough secretary without ever turning into Spillane’s Velda, tougher than her boss. Halliday spices up the relationship between the two without keeping some sort of bizarre fantasy that she is a virgin or that they don’t share their apartment keys though nothing sexier than a morning after drink is shown. Halliday lets you fill in the blanks for yourself.
Although individual sales never came close Halliday and company in total paperback sales figures rivaled Spillane in a far from generic way.
October 25th, 2026 at 2:57 am
I never felt Shayne was generic in fact he was one of the few eyes in the Spade tradition who developed much character of his own and followed Hammett’s tradition of having an actual mystery to solve and not just speeding cars, guns, fists, and pretty girls.
Lucy eventually evolved into a pretty tough cookie, tougher than Phylis Bentley nee Shayne (who ironically has the same maiden name as the oft kidnapped Mrs. Bulldog Drummond) and while Halliday stayed out of the bedroom, he was pretty clear about the relationship between the boss and secretary.
I think this one was adapted as the first of the three Dell Comic Book editions of Michael Shayne Private Detective. All three were adaptations of Halliday novels.
October 25th, 2026 at 10:45 am
The early Shayne novels (before Phyllis dies between books) are a unique blend of hardboiled action, screwball comedy, and Golden Age Detection, with Shayne often gathering the suspects near the end to explain the murder(s) and name the killer. I’ve never come across anything else quite like them. They’re enough to make me wish Hollywood hadn’t insisted Shayne had to be single, because that development really changed the tone of the rest of the series.
October 26th, 2026 at 11:50 am
As to whether the Mike Shayne books are generic or not depends, I think, on your definition of the word generic. From the dictionsray”
1
a
: relating to or characteristic of a whole group or class : general
“Romantic comedy” is the generic term for such films.
b
: not being or having a particular brand name
generic drugs
c
: having no particularly distinctive quality or application
generic restaurants
Numbers a and c seem relevant. They’re not quite the same.
As for Lucy Hamilton, I may be wrong about this, but I think her role in the stories grew more and more positive as time went on.
October 26th, 2026 at 7:04 pm
I didn’t read the review as being particularly negative (save the bit about Lucy Hamilton). The reviewer called Shayne “‘the’ Generic Private Eye”. Not ‘a’ generic private eye—but ‘the’. Add the fact that he puts ‘Generic Private Eye’ in capital letters and I think what he might be saying is that Shayne is the Platonic form of the hardboiled private eye. You couldn’t get away with imitating Sam spade or Philip Marlowe without getting cat called a copycat. But Shayne? You might be able to get away with that.
October 27th, 2026 at 3:18 pm
I couldn’t come up with a better analysis than that, Tony, and believe me, I’ve tried!
November 2nd, 2026 at 9:42 pm
Generic to me suggests lacking individuality which can’t be said of Shayne who is far from the fedora and Trenchcoated eye of say Pete MacGraph, Johnny Liddell, or Rocky Steele.
Shayne’s Miami setting, his greed, his brains (short of Spade he maybe the smartest eye rivaling Donald Lam and even Perry Mason), his loyalty to clients, his success (he’s no downtrodden broken down eye), and the involvement of his revolving cast of buddies and enemies are all distinctive which is far from the generic eye. He does not go off on Chandler style quests, but makes sure he gets paid and he’s not particularly sentimental in the avenging Spillane style. Shayne is very much a professional private detective with references to working in the oilfields doing security, catching a late night shift for a security guard he employees, and generally running a thriving business outside of individual cases.
Only Spicer’s Carney Wilde and Gardner’s Paul Drake run as successful a business as more than a lone wolf roaming mean streets.
If nothing else you would know Shayne if you saw him. Just a lot of eyes from the period are quite literally so generic you would need ID badges to tell them apart. Not Shayne.