Sat 25 Oct 2025
Diary Review: ELLERY QUEEN’S MYSTERY MAGAZINE – December 1967.
Posted by Steve under Diary Reviews , Magazines[6] Comments
ELLERY QUEEN’S MYSTERY MAGAZINE. December 1967. Overall rating: ***
JON L. BREEN “The Austin Murder Case.” A parody-pastiche of Philo Vance, who uncovers a murderer at a masquerade party, Hilarious footnotes. (5)

JACOB HAY “The Name of the Game,” A Russian school for spies sends a couple to pose as Americans. Expected ending, but with a haunting sense of unreality, (4)
JOHN DICKSON CARR “The Man Who Saw the Invisible.” Colonel March. First published in The Strand Magazine, April 1938, as “The New Invisible Man” by Carter Dickson. An impossible situation revealed as a magician’s trick. (3)
ANTHONY GILBERT “The Intruders.” After terror, a twist makes everything OK for the old lady, but happily? The terror is real. (4)
CHARLOTTE ARMSTRONG “More Than One Kind of Luck.” A would-be killer finds that he makes his own bad luck. (2)
G. C. EDMUNDSON “A Question of Translation.” It would help the reader to have knowledge of both Spanish and Italian. (3)
EDWARD D. HOCH “The Spy Who Didn’t Exist.” An obscure piece of knowledge helps Rand decipher a calendar code. (3)
AGATHA CHRISTIE “The Adventure of the Egyptian Tomb.” Hercule Poirot. First published in The Sketch, September 26, 1923. Belief in the supernatural is a powerful force, one Poirot must face, But why does he fake being poisoned? (2)
JOHN HOLT “Number One.” First story. A “practical” joke on a paroled con backfires into murder. (5)
PHYLLIS BENTLEY “Miss Phipps Goes to the Hairdresser.” If the wig wasn’t obvious, I don’t know what was. A waste. (1)
URSULA CURTISS “Change of Climate.” An elaborate buildup is ruined by an editor’s note which explains the whole story. Climate as a murder weapon. (3)
JOE GORES “File #1: The Mayfield Case.” Daniel Kearny Associates. Telling it as it isi n the private eye game: repossessing cars. (2)
October 26th, 2025 at 2:07 am
Some favorites here Hoch and Rand, Armstrong, Carr and March, Breen parody, Hay Secret Service stuff. Obviously from the scores not a great issue, but fairly typical of the magazine at that point.
October 26th, 2025 at 12:03 pm
I think this issue was better than the scores I gave the individual stories. It really is a great list of authors, all names I still remember today.
October 26th, 2025 at 4:47 am
Basically an all-star lineup. I would have rated the Gores and the Armstrong much higher than you did. Agatha Christie’s short stories, particularly the Poirots, were hit-or-miss (far less so with Miss Marple). Breen’s parodies are always welcome. Hoch is always inventive, although I personally rank his Rand stories lower than those featuring other charqcters. Edmondson was best known for his science fiction and his westerns. I never cared much for Miss Phipps, but she was popular with two dozen stories over thirty years, including 17 over a twenty-year stretch in EQMM. Holt went on to publish a half dozen paperback horror novels, some as “Raymond Giles.”
All in all, a fairly nifty issue.
October 26th, 2025 at 12:00 pm
A nifty issue, all right. I totally agree. Of all the info you added, Jerry, what I found the most interesting was that Holt went on from his First Story in this issue to become Raymond Giles. I looked him up as Holt, or tried to, and didn’t find much. Nothing at all, actually. Here’s a link to a blog post that talks a lot about the books he did as Giles:
https://darkeyesoflondon.blogspot.com/2020/09/dark-eyes-retro-reads-2-nels-of-raymond.html
October 26th, 2025 at 9:23 am
Danny rather perversely good at foolishly? giving away the game with some of his headnotes.
I’ll have to dig out that issue and see if I would rate that Gores story, at very least, higher as well…I like the series, and Gores was bracingly nihilist in the stories I would read in AH PRESENTS: anthologies as a kid.
Potemkin Village stories are often fascinating to me, as well.
October 26th, 2025 at 12:07 pm
I still have this issue myself, somewhere. If I could find it, I’d love to read it again. And being older now, maybe I’d like the Gores story better than I did the first time around. I’d like to know.