Sat 28 Mar 2026
SF Diary Review: GALAXY SCIENCE FICTION – December 1967.
Posted by Steve under Uncategorized[6] Comments
GALAXY SCIENCE FICTION – December 1967. EditorL Frederik Pohl. Cover artist: Gray Morrow. Overall rating: **½.

POUL ANDERSON “Out[pst of Empire.” Dominic Flandry. Novella. John Ridenour is sent as a troubleshooter to find out why the natives of Freehold seem to be rising up against the planet’s colonists, The situation is complicated by the was against Merseia because of Freehold’s strategic position near the empire’s boundary. Ridenour’s discovers, although slowly, that the natives, who have applied the scientific method to the problem of living in the wilderness, are more fit to represent the planet for Earth. Flower power!
Anderson is inclined to long-winded explanations here – even his characters realize it – and the story begins in the middle, and continues with unbelievable sluggishness. Plus a singularly obtuse ending, as it makes its way to an effective solution, ruins the rest. **½
[Note: I am informed that this is a Dominic Flandry story, but since I didn’t mention him back when I wrote this review, I cannot tell you what his role in it is now.]
RICHARD WILSON “The South Waterford Rumble Club.” Aliens flood Earth with counterfeit money, Rather dumb, but I was hopeful until the end, (1)
ROBERT SILVERBERG “King of the Golden World.” A woman who marries an alien chieftain realizes her responsibilities. (3)
FRITZ LEIBER “Black Corridor.” A man’s choices, or what makes makes a man. Nothing to add except style, (4)
PHILIP LATHAM “The Red Euphoria Bands.” The diary of an astronomer who discovers a comet’s beneficial properties. (3)
JOHN BRUNNER “Galactic Consumer Report No. 3.” Non-fact article.Ish, (0)
LARRY NIVEN “Handicap.” Novelette. Known Space. Some races have intelligence, but have no means to implement it. The ending fails because Niven assumes familiarity with his created universe, A potentially higher rating otherwise. (4)
HARRY HARRISON “The Fairly Civil Service,” A civil service of the future. (2)
Rating: **
March 29th, 2026 at 3:41 am
Not a favorite Flandry tale, he’s offstage much of it, but my score was overall higher with that lineup.
March 29th, 2026 at 9:03 am
Thanks for placing Flandry’s role in the story better than I did (not at all). It really had me puzzled. I’ve never been as big a fan of Anderson’s stories as I think I should be, but I think I’ll let my comments about this one help explain why.
By the way, the biggest problem I’ve having with the blog is that I can’t edit posts once they’re online. Not easily, that is, and if I try, I lose the comments. The overall rating should be 2.5 stars, as it says at the top of the page, not the more meager 2 stars at the bottom. I don’t know where that came from. And that strange word in the Anderson title should be Outpost. I suppose everyone figured that out anyway. Just hoping!
And you’re right about about the lineup of authors in this issue, David. Maybe it doesn’t qualify as an All Star issue in that regard, but it comes awfully close!
March 30th, 2026 at 9:41 am
That is a sad drawback to this blogging software, though you could copy and repost the comments, as awkward as that could be…re-adding web addresses, etc.
One trouble for a December issue of Pohl’s GALAXY is that it would closely follow, in the monthly or bimonthly sequence given the year, the October anniversary issues, which might tend to suck up much of the better material in inventory. Pohl might not’ve been That happy with this issue, if not willing to squeeze in an All-Star tag or some analog (koff) himself…
March 30th, 2026 at 10:52 am
“…though you could copy and repost the comments, as awkward as that could be…re-adding web addresses, etc…”
Alternative number 2, if I had the time to implement it. Possibility #1 is to turn off the now and not improved security system long enough to make any edits needed (this is what’s causing the problem) and then turn it back on.
As for Pohl’s success with the magazines, I am sure knowing all of the authors working and making names for themselves at the time didn’t hurt at all.
March 30th, 2026 at 10:37 am
I was subscribing to GALAXY in 1967. As I recall, Frederik Pohl was editing GALAXY, IF, and WORLDS OF TOMORROW. Busy guy…
March 30th, 2026 at 10:46 am
And all three were wonderful magazines, too, still fondly remembered! I wasn’t a subscriber, as I recall, but I sure haunted the local newsstand to make sure I never missed an issue of any of the three.