Fri 21 Aug 2026
DOUG ALLYN “The Iron Maiden.” Michelle “Mitch” Mitchell, Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine, November-December 2923.

The online Crime Fiction Index lists only two stories featuring deep sea diver Mitch Mitchell, but there are others yet to be found and so designated. This I know because this is one and it is not (yet) so noted. There is an interesting story about this as well, told as a short introduction to “The Iron Maiden.”
When the series began, with “Icewater Mansions,” a novelette in the January 1992 issue of EQMM, the hero was Brian Mitchell, also called Mitch. When the story expanded into a novel a few years later, the character had turned gender on us, and had become Michelle
“Mitch” Mitchell.
Also of note, perhaps, is that in same blurb that exists before this story begins, it tells us that Brian Mitchell was a Lake Michigan diver. While reading this one, I really really though was taking place in and on Lake Huron. (I could easily be wrong, but I don’t think I am.)
No matter, really. What this story is about is the search for a small ship that went lost a number of years ago, one that, now located, is the main attraction for two competing crews, both presuming the boat may still be the hiding place for a small treasure of “pirates” gold. Mitch is in one team, and as it turns out, an old friend from her past is on the other.
It’s minor tale, overall, with lots and lots of action, but what also caught my attention was the eerie feeling I felt as Mitch is under water, her air supply starting to run out, and she finds the boat … and a whole lot more. Underwater diving is a sport (and a job) that’s definitely not for me.
August 22nd, 2026 at 6:05 am
Allyn is consistently one of my favorite contemporary mystery short story writers.
August 22nd, 2026 at 12:22 pm
I don’t keep track of such things, but I think Doug Allyn and Ed Hoch are tied (or close to it) in terms of their short stories being reviewed on this blog.
August 24th, 2026 at 7:29 am
It’s a bad morning for year typos in the blogs I read…George Kelley has one, as well. I’ll have to see if I have that issue of EQMM to check back into…
August 24th, 2026 at 7:59 pm
Whatever you learn would be welcome, Todd. I don’t know why I love all this stuff, but I do.
August 30th, 2026 at 3:22 am
Jeff Meyerson beat me to it, but I was going to comment that Allyn has filled some of the gap left in the genre by Hoch, though he is a somewhat more consistent novelist.