October 2026
Monthly Archive
Sat 10 Oct 2026
A 1001 MIDNIGHTS Review
by Bill Pronzini
WILLIAM H. HALLAHAN – Catch Me, Kill Me. Bobbs-Merrill, hardcover, 1977. Avon, paperback, 1978. Winner of the Edgar Award for Best Mystery Novel from the MWA in 1978.

A former creative director for a large New York ad agency. William Hallahan published his first novel, The Dead of Winter, in 1972. This chilling (in more ways than one) tale of vengeance and sudden death earned considerable praise and prompted Publishers Weekly to extol Hallahan as being “expert in the creation of evil atmosphere.” His subsequent novels have lived up to — and surpassed-the promise of that debut. Catch Me: Kill Me is among his best, of such quality and merit that it was awarded a 1977 Best Novel Edgar.
Typical of Hallahan’s more recent work (broad of theme and scope), it is both a novel of political intrigue and a probing character study of its three protagonists. In a men’s room at Grand Central Station, a Russian Jew named Boris Kotlikoff, a minor poet who defected to the United States two years previous, is inexplicably kidnapped by Russian diplomats attached to the U .N. Inexplicably because Kotlikoff left Russia with no state secrets and is in no way a threat to his homeland. Even the most astute cold-war experts are at a loss to guess why the Soviets would perpetrate such a volatile act on U.S. soil.

Three men arc involved in the search for Kotlikoff, who is apparently being held hostage somewhere in New York City. All three know each other, but only one-a CIA hatchet man named Gus Geller-has official government sanction, and that of the top-secret variety. One of the other two is working with Geller: a discredited ex-CIA agent, Charlie Brewer, whose methods can be as brutal as they are unorthodox. The third man is Ben Leary, legal counsel for the Bureau of Immigration and Naturalization, who refuses to be put off his own line of inquiry.
Suspense builds to edge-of-the-chair proportions as Geller, Brewer, and Leary battle a variety of obstacles — and each other — to find Kotlikoff and uncover the amazing truth behind his abduction. Hallahan’ s distinctive, clipped prose style is particularly effective here; and he once again proves himself a master of the unexpected plot twist and the surprise climax. Even readers who don’t generally care for Us-versus-Them novels will find Catch Me: Kill Me absorbing.
———
Reprinted with permission from 1001 Midnights, edited by Bill Pronzini & Marcia Muller and published by The Battered Silicon Dispatch Box, 2007. Copyright © 1986, 2007 by the Pronzini-Muller Family Trust.
Thu 8 Oct 2026
ELLERY QUEEN’S MYSTERY MAGAZINE – February 1968. Overall rating: ***

STANLEY ELLIN “The Last Bottle in the World.” Novelet, A story that wine lovers will really enjoy the most. Ending a bit weak, but Ellin stands high above every other writer of the suspense story, (5)
DOROTHY L. SAYERS “A Matter of Taste.” First appeared in Lord Peter Views the Body (Gollancz, UK, 1928, as “The Bibulous Business of a Matter of Taste”.) A test by wine tasting, but it is obvious who the real Lord Wimsey is. (2)
CHARLES A. PETERSON “The Arithmetic of Poison” Poison from the office coffee machine, Effective, (3)
EDWARD D. HOCH “The Spy Who Clutched a Playing Card.” Rand of Double-C deciphers a clue given by the ten of clubs, (2)
HELEN HUDSON “The Thief.” First appeared in The Reporter, January 12, 1967, as “A Constant Caller.” Good story of a reclusive old lady, spoiled by poetic ending, (3)
HENRY T, PARRY “The Baker Street Irregulars Murder Case.” A waste of paper, (0)
ELLERY QUEEN “The Inner Circle.” Novelet. First appeared in Ellery Queen’s Mystery Magazine, January 1947, as “The Adventure of the Inner Circle.” A club, and a secret society within that club, and a secret society within that select society… (4)
CHRISTIANNA BRAND “The Wicked Ghost.” A story of a haunting, to be believed or not, meant to discourage infidelity, (5)
JAMES HOLDING “The Philippines Kay Mystery.” Martin Leroy & King Danforth. Escape from a bamboo prison, with a tedious epilogue. (2)
JAMES POWELL “The Eye of Shafti.” Fantasy and Fable. Comic story of the stolen eye of an idol. Slowed by it own ending, (2)
WILLIAM MacHARG “Tell ’Em at Headquarters.” O’Malley. First appeared in Collier’s, September 17 1932, as “Soiled Diamonds.” Hold-up in a taxi. Diamonds in a soup. (2)
ROBERT J. TILLEY “The Great Golf Mystery.” Near slapstick story of golf nuts. (3)
ROBERT L. FISH “The Adventure of the Disappearance of Whistler’s Mother.” Schlock Homes cracks Louvre kidnapping case, in his own style. (4)
LAWRENCE TREAT “B As in Blackmail.” Mitch Taylor & Bill Decker. Mitch Taylor loses a miniature microphone, and credit for solving a murder he listened in on. (#)
–September 1969
Tue 6 Oct 2026

THE WOMAN IN THE WINDOW. RKO Radio Pictures, 1944. Edward 6. Robinson, Joan Bennett, Raymond Massey, Dan Duryea. Based on a novel by J. H. Wallis. Director: Fritz Lang
What could possibly happen to a middle-aged professor left alone for the summer when his wife and family go on vacation without him? Would you believe a chance meeting with a beautiful woman, a few drinks, an enraged lover, then murder — strictly self-defense?
Moving the body is not a great idea. As the noose slowly tightens, Robinson does a stellar Job of portraying an utterly defeated man, especially when the blackmailer comes along — and he does. The ending is a whiz. Make it a double whiz. First rate.
— Reprinted from Movie.File.2, April 1988.
Tue 6 Oct 2026
I won’t bore you with more tales of woe, but I’m raring to get back in the saddle again. And it’s about time!
Fri 2 Oct 2026
CERI JORDAN “Rough Justice.” First published in Alfred Hitchcock’s Mystery Magazine, July/August 2001. Reprinted in The Shamus Winners: America’s Best Private Eye Stories, Volume II: 1992-2009, edited by Robert J. Randisi (Perfect Crime Books, 2010).

Here’s am award winning PI story which I’m willing to wager (but not too much) which you’ve never heard of, neither the author nor the story itself. I’m also will to shake your hand if you have. I came across it Robert Randisi’s collection of PWA award-winning short stories, which I highly recommend in case you don’t already own a copy.
Authors include the likes of Jeremiah Healy, Loren Estlemnan and Warren Murphy, all of whom I know you know; but also writers such as Mitch Alderson, Pearl Abraham and Michel Wiecek, whom you probably as much in the dark about as I am.
Also in the latter group is Ceri Jordam, whose only story to have been published in a major crime fiction magazine is this one. Most of her work, which includes dozens of short stories, has bern published in small press literary magazines and the like, most of which I’m not familiar with either. Its leading protagonist is a PI only by common consent. What he really has been doing, when this story starts, is a UN training instructor in the Balkans after all the hostilities there a quarter century or so ago.
He was the closest (and most reliable) man they could find to investigate the death of a sergeant for the UN Forces whose body has been found off base and whose death needs to be looked into. It seems as though he had been making a habit of such extracurricular activities. It is not expected to be a major case. Most likely, a jealous hatband was responsible.
And that’s about all of the clues they have, but Nick, while not enthused, does take his job seriously. I did refer to the time period as “post war,” long before any reconstruction has begun, and I have to tell you that this is the grimmest PI story I have ever read.
And that’s about all I am going to tell you about this one. Is it well written? Yes/ Am I happy I read it? Yes, I think so, but I also should add that I’m not as sure about that. Do I recommend you find a copy? Well, of course, or I wouldn’t have brought it up
« Previous Page